Tuesday, November 8

Mani's Magic

Posted by Picasa

He is arguably one of the best directors in operation in the Indian movie world. The consistency with which he manages to make commercial success's of social themes is something that would be difficult for any director to emulate.I present the top three movies directed by him from his list. This list is subjective hence others are welcome to give in their inputs. Top 3 of Mani-

Rank 3: Roja One of the ground breaking movies of Indian Cinema,this made history of sorts for a variety of reasons - The music was given by a 23 yr old youngster who was paid a remuneration of Rs 25,000 for this movie which was his debut. But what would stand out in this movie is the amazing screenplay which unfolds frame by frame. Mani does an brilliant job all through movie etching each character perfectly and justifying their presence and roles very clearly. Madhu walks away with the acting credits although she never could recreate the magic again. While Aravind Swamy stole a thousand hearts with his Red Sweatshirt and amazing screen presence..
Favourite Song: Puthu Vellai Mazhai
Favourite Scene: Aravind Swamy putting out the fire on the national flag by rolling over it.
Favourite Dialogue: Actually cant think of one..

Rank 2: Alaipayuthe - Like the previous one this movie launched a face that became a rage of the State. The beauty with which Mani unfolds the love story of Karthik & Shakti speaks volumes of his talent in Movie making. A parallel telling in which the flash back merges with the original story towards the end of the movie is wonderful. The amazing dialogues between the various characters involved in the movie with each playing their role to perfection. The Scene in which Karthik's dad talks to him about his younger days as an hardworking and well disciplined youngster is something every one would have had with their dad at somepoint in their life. The conversation between Karthiks and Shaktis parents are also beautifully portrayed.
Favourite Song: Snehithane
Favourite Scene: When Madhavan gets caught trying to bring Poorni(shakti's sis) and her fiance' together.
Favourite Dialogue: "Karthik,nee panakaranna? classle lastaa? yenna, panakara pasanga thaan intha mathiri padikaratha vittitu ponunga pinnadi suthuvaanga." ( That smile..aaah.)

Rank 1: Mouna Ragam- This one ranks right up there. The first commercial movie of Mani. A indicator of what was to redefine the tamil film industry. The storyline is to date one of the best that I can think of. Mohan as the loving husband, Revathi as the full of life young girl whose world is shattered after the death of her lover and finally Karthik as the happy, fun loving hearthrob steals the show. Some of the songs and their lyrics are really amazing and touching. I could just go on....
Favourite Song: Nilaave Vaa..(One Amazing song...touches you everytime you listen to it)
Favourite Scene: When Karthik invites Revathis dad for a cup of coffee at the restaurant.
Favourite Dialogue: "Neena kettathu onu...Naana aasai pattu vaangitu vanthathu onu...." ( Mohan is a class act in this one)

5 Comments:

Blogger TamilPonnu said...

Mani Ratnam is my fav!! all time FAV!! I love Mouna Raagam- Fell in love with karthik.. haha.. totally Agree with you about the fav. scenes..

ManiRatnam Vaazhha! :)

8:29 AM  
Blogger Bart said...

Kadalais, My money is on mani's following honeys..
Rank # 3: I disagree. Roja wouldn't fall here. The initial portions where Arvindsamy goes to village in hunt for a bride and the way in which villagers are depicted was a bit amateurish. Mani has never been fully comfortable in a village (this can be observed in Thiruda, thiruda, Dhajmagaal (screenplay by mani) too).
I would place "Idhayathai thirudathey" aka "Geetanjali" in Telugu here. This movie was great and a trendsetter for a beautiful love story where hero and heroine are affected by disease but still not shown within sobs and sorrow. Totally tangential treatment of a sad theme. PC.Sreeram and Ilayaraja were just amazing. The youthfulness and bubble in the movie just stays with you for long. Mind you, this was much before 'Chandramouli', 'karthik & shakti' et al. The negative of the movie is its cheap comedy track involving VKR.
Rank # 2: 'Alaipayuthey', i would rank it at 4 alongside with 'Iruvar'. Somehow, "Nayagan", in my view deserves this slot. This was a movie that brought the best out of Kamal. More importantly, though it is said to be a indianized 'Godfather'. This just has similar backdrop and nothing beyond that. But the sequences and the flow was just amazing. There are lots of immortal dialogues like "naalu perukku.. " and "neenga nallavara..." etc. It is a perfect example of how a person's biography (Varadaraja mudaliyar) can be told in an entertaining cinematic medium. IR is again a lifeline alongwith PC. Negative of the movie perhaps is the item song with Kuyili (though a good song).
Rank #1: I agree. Mounaraagam is a classic which stands out for telling a family story with poise. It stands out for the flashback sequence and the 'gentleman'liness of Mohan's character. The negative of the movie, if any, could be the hindi speaking VKR and Tamil speaking Sardar (a comedy meant for school children). A refreshing treatment again of a gloomy story.

P.S.: I haven't seen Mani's "Pallavi Anupallavi" in Kannada. Rest were considered.

11:43 PM  
Anonymous Anonymous said...

I don't agree with rank 2. From directorial and screenplay perspective Nayagan or Geetanjali are better than roja. ofcourse roja had the very good theme.

One more interesting thing in Alaipayithe is that Shakti literally says "I Love You" only at the climax ....i don't why???

11:00 AM  
Blogger Raya Speaks said...

Hey Kanna,
Write more. I'm waiting for some more interesting text on your log.

10:55 AM  
Blogger SriramSharma said...

True to the blog, mounaragam is one of my favourite too.... Karthik calling revathi's father for coffee, is an evergreen comedy.

3:39 PM  

Post a Comment

<< Home